Report on four dives on the Saba Bank, 17 and 18 July 1999
Paul Hoetjes, Mark Vermeij and Andy Caballero

Introduction

On July 17 and 18, 1999, four dives were made on the Saba Bank, a 1600 km2 (depth<50 m) sunken atoll, approximately 4 miles offshore from the island of Saba (Netherlands Antilles). All dives took place in the Upper North East corner of the Bank. Because of damage to the handheld GPS, the positions of the first two dives on July 17 could not be recorded, although a rough estimation of the position of the first dive could be made (see fig. 1 and table 2). The purpose of the dives was to investigate the local environment values of the Saba Bank, an area that is a very important fishing ground for local fishermen, especially for lobster (Panulirus argus). Where the dives took place in a coral reef area they also presented an opportunity to get an impression of the health and the state of the coral reef of the Bank.

Description of the dive sites

During the first dive a flat, solid limestone rock bottom was encountered at a depth of 60 ft, covered with sparse coral rubble and thin patches of sand. A dense monospecific cover of the brown algae Dictyopteris justii was present here (bottom coverage > 80%), interspersed occasionally with a strikingly green specimen of the green alga Codium isthmocladum
Gorgonians, mostly Pseudopterogorgia spp., were a regular occurrence. A few scattered large specimens of the Barrel Sponge (Xestospongia muta) were observed. These, and occasional dead or living coral heads that rise from the flat bottom, provide habitats occupied by Coneys (Epinephelus fulvus), Red Hinds (E. guttatus), Squirrelfishes (Holocentrus adscensionis). Schools of White Margates (Haemulon album) were seen swimming over the algae beds (fig. 2), sometimes associated with a few (<3) large Bar Jacks (Caranx ruber). Parrotfish (Scarus vetula, S. viride, S. aurofrenatum, S. rubripinne, S. chrysopterum, Scarus taeniopterus and S. croicensis) and doctorfish (Acanthurus chirurgus/bahianus) were omnipresent (>50 individuals/dive). Queen Triggerfish (Balistes vetula) and Grey Angelfish (Pomacanthus arcuatus) were sighted in lower numbers (1 to 5 individuals/dive), as well as one Southern Stingray (Dasyatis americana). At the end of the first dive the bottom became sandier and a few conch were seen. On July 18, during the second dive we found the same bottom characteristics at a depth of 60 ft, however no sandy areas were encountered and no conch were seen. From a cursorial survey from the boat, it appears that this habitat extends over much of the shallowest parts of the Bank, at least in the northeastern part. Similar habitat is not found around St. Maarten, but it was very similar to the shallow plateau on the windward sides of Curaçao and Bonaire, where however the predominant alga is Sargassum sp.

On July 17 the second dive (exact position unknown, but on the northern edge of the Bank immediately facing Saba) was performed on a sloping part of the Bank near the North edge, starting at a depth of 60 ft till a depth of about 90 ft. The bottom consisted mostly of sand here, but outcroppings of (dead) coral were seen more than during dives 1 and 4 on the plateau of the Bank. A few Conch were seen, and another stingray.

  Fig. 3. View of the reef at 80 ft. Groove and spur-like
              formations on a flat bottom.
Coral Reef

During the first dive on July 18 at a depth of 80 ft the highest abundance of corals was encountered. The reef consisted of large stretches of coral rising up to 8 ft from sand valleys and sand patches that alternated with the reef, in a kind of spur and groove formation (fig. 3). A total of 32 coral species were observed (table 1). Many of the coral colonies were large (especially the Montastrea species), but many others were much smaller compared to colonies growing on undisturbed reefs in the same region. In between the corals an unusually dense layer of macro algae was present, composed mainly of Dictyota divaricata, 5-10 cm high (fig. 4), but areas covered with Lobophora variegata were also common. Compared to St. Maarten or Curaçao this reef was situated much deeper than similar reefs found around the other islands. The amount of macro algae present was striking and would seem to indicate some source of nutrients, perhaps caused by upwelling along the edge of the Bank.

Many corals suffered from partial mortality, apparently recent (within the past 3-5 years). Yellow Blotch/Band (fig. 5)and Dark-Spot disease were seen regularly, but were not rampant. Partial bleaching was observed in a colony of Dendrogyra cylindrica (fig. 6). From this very limited impression, the health of this reef seemed in worse state than similar reefs around St. Maarten and Curaçao. For a pristine reef free of human impact this seems cause for concern. More research is needed to provide data on the state of the coral health.

Fig 4. Lush growth of Dictyota divaricata on
dead coral patches
Adjacent to the coral reef area a larger stretch of flat sandy bottom was encountered, in many places with a thin patchy cover of a blue-green algae (Schizotrix calcicola?). Some patches of coral were scattered on this sand bottom . No live Conch (some small dead ones were present) were observed here.

Fishes observed in this coral reef area included numerous Queen Triggerfish (> 10 individuals), and Red Hinds. Two individuals of the Yellowfin Grouper (Mycteroperca venenosa) were observed, (± 40 cm and 90 cm). Whitespotted Filefish (Cantherhines macroceros) (2 individuals) and Gray Angelfish (Pomacanthus arcuatus) (2 individuals) were also seen. Despite this, fishes seemed to be rather scarce. Fishes such as Yellowtail Snappers and Tangs, common elsewhere, were notably absent here.
Fig 5. Yellow-blotch disease on Montastrea faveolata Fig 6. Partially bleached colony of Dendrogyra cylindricus

                                                                
 

Table 1. The following coral species (32) were found during dive 3:.
 
Montastrea faveolata P. branneri Mycetophyllia ferox
M. cavernosa P. porites M. aliceae/lamarckiana
Colpophyllia natans Madracis mirabilis Scolymia cubensis
Diploria strigosa M. decactis Isophyllastrea rigida
D. labyrinthiformis M. pharensis Mussa angulosa
Meandrina meandrites M. asperula Millepora alcicornis
Siderastrea siderea Eusmilia fastigiata Dendrogyra cylindricus
Stephanocoenia michelini Agaricia agaricites Tubastrea aurea
Solenastrea sp A. lamarcki/grahami Oculina sp.
Dichocoenia stokesi A. fragilis Millepora alcicornis
Porites asteroides Leptoseris cucullata

 

Table 2. Locations, depth and bottomtype of the dives made
Date Longitude Latitude Depth Bottom type
17/7/99: Dive 1 W 63' 12,500" N 17' 27,000" 18 m (60 ft) Rock/Dictyopteris
17/7/99: Dive 2 n.a. n.a. 20-28 m (70-90 ft) Sand/algae-patchy corals
18/7/99: Dive 1 W 63' 13,000" N 17' 28,000" 24 m (80 ft) Coral Reef
18/7/99: Dive 2 W 63' 15,000" N 17' 28,000" 18 m (60 ft) Rock/Dictyopteris